Two suppliers quote you the same product at the same price. One says FOB, while the other says CIF.

Are they offering the same deal?

Not necessarily. The Incoterm can change which costs you are responsible for, when risk transfers to you, and how you should compare the two quotations.

Incoterms® 2020 are standardized trade terms published by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC). They define key responsibilities between the seller and buyer, including delivery, transportation costs, and the point at which the risk of loss or damage transfers.

They do not determine the ownership or title of the goods, the purchase price, or payment terms.

The two things you need to understand: cost and risk

When comparing Incoterms, focus on two questions:

1. When does the risk transfer?

This is the point at which the buyer becomes responsible for the risk of loss or damage to the goods.

2. Which party is responsible for each cost and obligation?

This can include transportation, export and import formalities, insurance, and other costs depending on the specific Incoterm.

Once you understand these two points, comparing supplier quotations becomes much easier.

The Incoterms small importers commonly encounter

EXW — Ex Works

The seller makes the goods available at their premises, such as a factory or warehouse.

The buyer is generally responsible for arranging transportation from the seller's location, as well as export and import formalities.

EXW can look attractive because the quoted product price may be low, but it puts a significant amount of the logistics process on the buyer.

For international shipments, buyers should also consider whether EXW is practical in the country of export, particularly when the buyer is not established there.

FOB — Free On Board

Under FOB, the seller delivers the goods on board the vessel at the named port of shipment.

The risk transfers to the buyer once the goods are on board the vessel.

The seller handles the export formalities and the costs required to get the goods on board. The buyer normally arranges and pays for the main international freight and insurance from that point onward.

FOB is a sea and inland-waterway rule. For containerized or multimodal shipments, consider FCA and agree the precise named delivery place with your logistics provider. ICC guidance distinguishes delivery to a carrier or terminal from delivery on board a vessel.

CFR — Cost and Freight

CFR is similar to FOB, except that the seller also arranges and pays for the freight to the named destination port.

However, the risk still transfers to the buyer when the goods are loaded on board the vessel at the port of shipment.

The buyer is responsible for arranging insurance if insurance is required.

CIF — Cost, Insurance and Freight

CIF is similar to CFR, but the seller also arranges and pays for insurance covering the buyer's risk during the transportation to the named destination port.

An important point is that the risk does not transfer when the goods arrive at the destination port.

Under CIF, risk transfers to the buyer when the goods are loaded on board the vessel at the port of shipment.

So CIF does not mean that the seller remains responsible for the goods until they safely arrive at your warehouse.

It is also important to understand the scope of the insurance provided under CIF. The standard CIF insurance requirement may provide only limited coverage, so buyers with higher-value or higher-risk shipments may want to consider additional insurance.

DAP — Delivered at Place

Under DAP, the seller arranges transportation and delivers the goods to the named destination, ready for unloading.

The buyer is generally responsible for import clearance, import duties, and applicable taxes.

DAP can be useful when you want the seller to handle most of the transportation while keeping control of the import clearance process.

DDP — Delivered Duty Paid

Under DDP, the seller takes on most of the delivery obligations, including export and import clearance, transportation, and payment of applicable import duties and taxes.

The seller delivers the goods to the named destination, ready for unloading.

DDP can be convenient for buyers, but it is important to understand exactly how the seller is handling customs clearance and import compliance.

FOB vs. CIF: the comparison trap

Suppose Supplier A quotes:

$10 FOB Shenzhen

Supplier B quotes:

$10 CIF Los Angeles

These are not equivalent quotations.

The CIF price includes the seller's freight and insurance costs to the named destination port, while the FOB price does not include the main international freight arranged by the buyer.

To compare the two suppliers properly, you need to account for the costs included in each quotation and calculate the total landed cost under the same assumptions.

Neither FOB nor CIF is automatically cheaper.

CIF may be more convenient because the seller arranges the freight and insurance, while FOB gives the buyer more control over the main transportation and the choice of freight forwarder.

The important thing is to compare the total cost, not just the product price shown on the quotation.

A warning about DDP offers

Some suppliers advertise very low-priced DDP shipping and say they will "handle everything with customs."

Don't assume that every DDP arrangement is the same.

Before accepting a DDP quotation, ask how the shipment will be declared, who will act as the importer, and how duties and taxes will be handled.

Be especially careful if a supplier suggests declaring an artificially low value or using inaccurate product information to reduce duties.

Incorrect customs declarations can create compliance problems, delays, additional costs, or penalties.

The key is to understand who is responsible for import clearance and whether the proposed process complies with the destination country's customs rules.

Which Incoterm should you use?

There is no single Incoterm that is best for every shipment.

Your choice depends on your experience, shipment size, destination, logistics setup, and how much control you want over transportation and customs.

For example:

FOB can be useful when you have your own freight forwarder and want more control over international transportation.

CIF can be convenient when you want the supplier to arrange the main freight and insurance to the destination port.

EXW can require more logistics work from the buyer and may be less practical if you don't have a logistics partner in China.

DAP can be useful when you want the seller to handle transportation to your destination while you handle import clearance.

DDP can simplify the process, but you should understand exactly how customs clearance and import compliance are being handled.

The right choice depends on the specific shipment rather than simply choosing the term with the lowest quoted price.

Tie Incoterms back to your landed cost

Whichever Incoterm you use, make sure you understand which costs are already included in the supplier's quotation and which costs you still need to pay.

This information should flow directly into your landed-cost calculation.

When comparing quotations, record the Incoterm alongside the product price. Otherwise, a lower-looking quotation may simply exclude costs that another supplier has already included.

Our Import Operations Toolkit includes a one-page Incoterms reference sheet and a quotation-comparison template to help you compare supplier offers using consistent terms.

Bottom line

Incoterms are not just a line of fine print on a quotation. They help define which party is responsible for key costs, obligations, and risks during the shipment.

When comparing suppliers, don't compare the product price alone. Check the Incoterm, understand when risk transfers, identify which costs are included, and calculate the total landed cost before making a decision.